Should i buy mac carbon eyeshadow or blacktrack fluidline?

I only have 20 dollars and im trying to get into black eyeshadow and the smokey eye look. So far the only eyeshadow item i own is smashbox's twilight trio with a black, silver, and white. but they're weird.Should i buy mac carbon eyeshadow or blacktrack fluidline?
If anything try to buy both if you can because if your trying to get into the black eyeshadow and smokey eye look, you'll need carbon for the eyeshadow for the smokey eye and the fluidline for the liner for top and bottom and the fluidline lasts a long time so thats a plus..


You should also try to invest in ';Dark Soul'; pigment because it can do both! You could use it to be an eyeshadow for the smokey eye look and can be mixed with mixing medium, matte, or even water to be used as an eyeliner! AND pigment is also $19.50 so its still under the $20 you have!


Hope I helped a little :)Should i buy mac carbon eyeshadow or blacktrack fluidline?
I would suggest the Blacktrack Fluidline, as a little goes a long way. But keep in mind, that it doesn't come with a brush, you will have to buy that separately if you don't have a liner brush.
HI I'M CHRISTINA A INDEPENDENT BEAUTY CONSULTANT WITH MARY KAY. I HAVE A WEBSITE YOU CAN CHECK OUT, YOU CAN UPLOAD YOUR PICTURE AND PLAY WITH COLOR AND HAIR. YOU CAN ALSO ORDER FROM THERE. HAVE FUN.


WWW.MARYKAY.COM/CHRISTINA105
I like MAC Fluidline. I have it in Blitz %26amp; Glitz, and I love it!


Tarte makes a smokey eye kit, by the way. You might want to check it out.








I hope this helps!
the blacktrack would stay longer, the carbon may fade away by time if u dont apply it well
Mac. Great quality and worth the money.