Should i purchase mac : eyeshadow or liquid liner?

goldmine eyeshadow or liquid eyeliner???


is the liquid eyeliner good? as in waterproof and smudge proof and the brush??Should i purchase mac : eyeshadow or liquid liner?
Goldmine eyeshadow is really pretty





The liquid liner is really good and last a really long time





Both are good, but I would buy both :)Should i purchase mac : eyeshadow or liquid liner?
eyeshadow


they are both probably really good, but out of the two, their eyeshadows are better i think.
Unless you're really good at applying the liner, then stick with shadow because it's safer and harder to screw up. If you're good at it, you could get liner. I would honestly get both. A girl can never have too much MAC. :-)
The first eyeshadow I bought from MAC was a nice purple, called 'Parfait Amour',


https://www.beautive.com/images/prod/l/03283383002.jpg


and I found this colour looked very nice on my eyes.


I also got MAC 'Engraved' eyeliner,


http://www.perfumezilla.com/images_product/mac-eye-care-1-2g-0-04oz-powerpoint-eye-pencil-engraved-women.jpg


I found that this eyeliner get used very quick, the sharperner is needed, and it is very smudgey.


I think that there is a gel eyeliner, which I heard was very good, but just need to be applicated by a brush, so you can have more control.


I struggle with Liquid eyeliner, so I wouldn't buy it.


Becky
I use brown down and shroom eyeshadow! Its class.


Don't use there mascara, its not good at all!
omg eyeshadow it wayyyyyyyyyyy better! i have like every color =D u should def but the eyeshadow
golmine eyeshadow

Why my cat is bleeding inside her ears